Pagina Principal  

English Report

Between May 12th and 16th, the Secretary of Public Security of the State of São Paulo published alarming data: in the 251 attacks by the prison gang First Command of the Capital (PCC), and its confrontation with the police, there were 115 deaths, including 32 police officers, 8 prison guards, and 75 people who were shot by both sides.

Violence in São Paulo – a frightening balance

Evanize Sydow[1]


Banks destroyed, bomb treats at bus stops and airports, shot up police vehicles, incinerated buses, and a population in panic. That was the situation in São Paulo on May 12, and the days that followed. Between May 12th and 16th, the Secretary of Public Security of the State of São Paulo published alarming data: in the 251 attacks by the prison gang First Command of the Capital (PCC), and its confrontation with the police, there were 115 deaths, including 32 police officers, 8 prison guards, and 75 people who were shot by both sides.

The transfer of eight prisoners, among them Marcola, a leader of the PCC, to the Department for Investigations of Organized Crime, provoked the first attacks. On the following day, there were uprisings in prisons all over the state, with 132 hostages taken. Buses and bank branches were attacked on Sunday, May 14th. In the state capital alone, the number of deaths was 44; uprisings also occurred in the states of Paraná and Mato Grosso do Sul, as well as in juvenile detention centers run by FEBEM (Foundation for the Well-being of Minors) in the state of São Paulo. The violence continued in the early morning hours, totaling 66 incinerated city buses, a prison guard killed on the street, and 4,000 buses not circulating throughout the city. Monday was grim: businesses closed their doors early, schools and universities suspended classes, and the city set a record for traffic jams – 195 kilometers of gridlock. According to the data from the Secretary of Prison Administration, from May 12th to 15th, nine prisoners were killed in the uprisings at 73 prisons in the state. Tuesday also had a negative balance: an attack on a police barracks in Rio Claro, in the interior of São Paulo state, shots fired and a grenade thrown at a community center in Osasco.[1]

On September 15th, 2006, the newspaper Folha de São Paulo reported that 493 people were killed between May 12th and 20th, the period of the first PCC attacks in São Paulo. The survey was done by the Regional Council of Medicine in the 23 Medical Legal Institutes of the state, and included all types of death by firearms, including suicides and domestic violence.

On September 21st, the newspaper Folha de São Paulo reported that shortly before the first attacks, Julinho Carambola, another PCC leader, had used bribery to obtain pay stubs and employee addresses from the Secretary of Public Administration, and that this data would be used to kill prison guards outside of the prisons. The report says that from May 12th until September 21st, 15 prison guards were killed, with at least eight of them attacked near their homes.

According to Antonio Funari Filho, the magistrate of the State Police of São Paulo, of the 47 victims of the attack attributed to the PCC, 24 were military police (including 2 firemen), eight civilian police, eight prison guards, three municipal guards, and four civilians.

Funari states that there were 87 civilian deaths in which the attackers were not identified. Of these 87 deaths, the majority (18) was in the southern part of the capital, 16 were in Guarulhos and 12 were in the northern part of the capital.

The numbers, as we can see, are variable. The fact is that the population of São Paulo witnessed, between May and August, three crime waves. The motives may be varied: lack of  effective social policies, a failed prison system, inadequate working conditions, police corruption, and low salaries. [2] And the remainder of innocent deaths is frightening.

Twenty-eight year-old Maurício Assis de Menezes is an example. He had worked in a family bar in Capão Redondo, in the southern zone of São Paulo, since he was 14 years old, and was known by the neighbors as a very quiet youth. On May 16th, he and seven friends went out on the street to unroll a string of lights that illuminated the snack bar. Without even having time to think about what was happening, the police ordered them to put their hands on the head. Men in baseball caps shot the boys in their backs. Of the seven, five died, including Maurício.[3]


[1] Terra Publishers. “Entenda a onda de violência contra a polícia em SP.” Available at http://noticias.terra.com.br/brasil/guerraurbana. (accessed on November 14, 2006)

[2] OJEDA, Igor. Violência começa por ausência do Estado. Brasil de Fato, May 18 to 24, 2006

[3] MELO, Dafne e MERLINO, Tatiana. Moradores denunciam crimes da polícia. Brasil de Fato, May 25 to 31, 2006


[1] Evanize Sydow is a journalist with the Social Network for Justice and Human Rights and has a Masters in Communications from the Center of Research and Documentation of Contemporary History of Brazil of the Getúlio Vargas Foundation in Rio de Janeiro.